Some names present pronunciation challenges.  Some descriptions present tasting challenges.  Some beers present challenges with both.  Xolotl by Avery brewing company provides an opportunity regarding both of these concerns.

Xolotl – Avery Brewing Company – I’m not sure how to say the name of this beer.  I have provided, in the title, what I feel are potential options. (Xylophone is my paltry attempt at humor.)  Maybe one or more of the letters is silent?  The name could be XQOLTZBCHNK for all intents and purposes, provided the beer in the vessel is delicious, and I would quickly disregard the awkwardness of the name.  In reviewing this brew, though, I find myself conflicted.  It smells prominently of sweet vanilla with slight hints of chilis and chocolate.  It maintains clear congruity with the stout style in its obsidian coloration.  In pouring it into a glass, it is topped with a flimsy head that dissipates so quickly that it is gone by the second sip.  The taste is smooth, sweet, velvety, and has mild elements of the chocolate and chilis promised on the label, but ultimately, tastes thin.  It could be, that I have undue expectations of delivery on label promises.  It could be, that my palate is not as discerning as I believe, and that certain promised elements are so delicate that I can’t pick them out.  But I don’t believe this is the case.  The cinnamon flavoring simply isn’t there.  As mentioned, the chilis, vanilla, and cacao/chocolate flavoring are certainly discernible.  My biggest contention is that the promise of bourbon barrel aging doesn’t seem to shine through at all.  I was anticipating a sweet, oaky heat to round this beer out, and sadly, it’s not there either.  Overall, this is a decent experience, it’s just not a next level one.  6.5/10

When I purchase a bottle, I am purchasing it with several elements in mind. I am purchasing based on style, brewery reputation, curiosity, value, uniqueness, and also, on the description provided on the label.  When I run into a situation where the beer I have purchased doesn’t truly meet several of my criteria, I feel compelled to discuss it, and in this case rather critically.  At $15 for a 12oz bottle,  any purchaser should have high expectations. This beer is a prime example of one that retails for a premium, yet delivers in a manner not consistent with the price tag.

I do enjoy most Avery offerings, but in this instance, the buyer should definitely temper expectations.

Humbly yours,

J